BASKETBALL

First Team
Anne Blair – 2002
Alison Kessler – 2006, 2007, 2008*
Erin Newsom – 2009
Anna Kammrath – 2010
Kelley Murphy – 2011, 2012

Second Team
Emily Creachbaum – 2003, 2004, 2005
Bridget Boyce – 2005, 2006
Bridget Lipke – 2006, 2007
Erin Newsom – 2007
Nicole Beier – 2009
Kelley Murphy – 2010
Maggie Ronan – 2011
Liz Wade – 2011
Jessica Centa – 2012
Patsy Mahoney – 2012
Shanlynn Bias – 2013, 2014
Ariana Paul – 2015
Krista Knapke – 2016
Gabby Diamond – 2018
Giavanna Paradiso – 2019, 2020

CROSS COUNTRY

First Team
Megan Gray – 2006, 2007
Brittany Beeler – 2015, 2016

Second Team
Jackie Bauters – 2001
Sara Otto – 2006
Megan McClowry – 2008
Julia Kenney – 2010
Jessica Biek – 2013
Brittany Beeler – 2014
Amanda Tracy – 2023

GOLF

First Team
Stefanie Simmerman – 2001, 2002, 2003*, 2004
Megan Mattia – 2002, 2003, 2005*
Julia Adams – 2003, 2004*
Chrissy Dunham – 2004
Katie O'Brien – 2007*
Rosie O'Connor – 2008*, 2010
Mary Kate Boyce – 2009, 2010*
Natalie Matuszak – 2009, 2011
Martyna Mierzwa – 2009*
Marin Beagley – 2010
Doyle O'Brien – 2010
Janice Heffernan – 2013, 2014
Paige Pollak – 2013
Samantha Averill – 2015*
Taylor Kehoe – 2016, 2018
Lauren Read – 2016, 2018
Hunter Kehoe – 2017, 2018*, 2019*, 2021*^
Summer Stillson – 2017, 2018, 2019
Sydney Hruskoci – 2018, 2019, 2021^
Haley Angel – 2024*
Julia Lizak – 2024

Second Team
Natalie Cook – 1999
Molly Lee – 1999
Jennifer DeWitt – 2000
Kyle Veltri – 2000
Megan Keleher – 2001
Liz Hanlon – 2002
Chrissy Dunham – 2002
Megan Mattia – 2004
Nicole Bellino – 2004, 2005
Kirsten Fantom – 2005
Katie O’Brien – 2005
Kate Doornbos – 2006
Emily Gore – 2007
Natalie Matuszak – 2008
Rosie O'Connor – 2009
Christine Brown – 2011
Justine Bresnahan – 2012
Janice Heffernan – 2012
Claire Boyle – 2012
Amanda Graham – 2012
Ali Mahoney – 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016
Courtney Carlson – 2016
Taylor Kehoe – 2017
Lauren Read – 2017
Sydney Hruskoci – 2021
Katelyn Tokarz – 2021, 2022
Amanda Melling – 2024

^ All-MIAA selections made in Spring 2021 due to COVID-19 delayed season. 
A change to the golf championship format beginning in 2023-24 also saw All-MIAA selections move to spring season.

LACROSSE

First Team
Kate Kelly – 2016, 2018, 2019
Rachael Leonard – 2017, 2018, 2019
Mary Singler – 2017*
Clare Theisen – 2017
Erin Doyle – 2018*, 2019*, 2021*
Emily Kraker – 2019*, 2021*
Kendra Osinski – 2019
Erin Dotson – 2021
Molly Mullett – 2021, 2023
Bridget Kane – 2022
Valentina Rubio – 2022

Second Team
Emilie Vanneste – 2015
Katlynn Dee – 2015, 2016
Kate Kelly – 2017
Kendra Osinski – 2018
Bridget Kane – 2019, 2021
Gabby Belsito – 2021, 2022
Sarah Frick – 2021
Erin Dotson – 2022, 2023
Lindsey Herdsman – 2023

SOCCER

First Team
Katy Barger – 1999
Jennifer Concannon – 2002, 2003, 2004
Carrie Orr – 2003, 2005
Katie Taylor – 2004
Ashley Hinton – 2005, 2006
Kerry Green – 2012, 2013, 2014
Chanler Rosenbaum – 2013
Mary Kate Hussey – 2013

Second Team
Jennifer Concannon – 2001
Lynn Taylor – 2002
Wendy Irvin – 2002
Carolyn Logan – 2003
Katie Taylor – 2003
Ashley Hinton – 2004
Lauren Hinton – 2005, 2006, 2008
Justine Higgins – 2007
Jessica Slean – 2009
Mollie Valencia – 2010, 2011, 2012
Chanler Rosenbaum – 2012
Mary Kate Hussey – 2012, 2014
Maggie McLaughlin – 2015
McKenna O'Shea – 2017
Rose Stackhouse – 2018, 2019, 2021
Margaret Slove – 2023

SOFTBALL

First Team
Andrea Arena – 1998
Kate Sajewich – 2004
Erin Sullivan – 2004*
Kristin Amram – 2006*, 2007
Sarah Miesle – 2006
McKenna Corrigan – 2008
Ashley Peterson – 2008, 2009, 2010*
Hayley Bojorquez – 2010
Lauren Enayati – 2011
Callie Selner – 2012, 2013
Jordie Wasserman – 2012
Jillian Busfield – 2013, 2014
Cassie Young – 2016*, 2017*, 2018
Jamie Young – 2016, 2017, 2018
Morgan Raymer – 2017, 2018
Makenzie Duncan – 2018

Second Team
Johanna Indriola – 1998
Rachel Deer – 1999
Kristin Martin – 2000
Susan Kutz – 2001
Marnie Walsh – 2002
Bridget Grall – 2003, 2006
Angie Ellison – 2004
Katrina Tebbe – 2004*
Audrey Gajor – 2005
Ashley Fusaro – 2006
Sarah Miesle – 2007
Katie Rashid – 2007
Cathy Kurczak – 2008
Lauren Enayati – 2010
Kate Mitchell – 2010
Kristen Nelson – 2012
Morgan Bedan – 2012, 2013
Jillian Busfield – 2015
Cassie Young – 2015
Jamie Young – 2015
Morgan Raymer – 2016
Makenzie Duncan – 2017
Jessica Alberts – 2018
Kelsey Keilman – 2018, 2019
Zoe Bruni – 2019
Mandi Hettinger – 2021
JoAnna Keilman – 2021
Alexis Rauch – 2022
Caitlin Traxler – 2023

SWIMMING

Megan Ramsey – 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004
Sarah Nowak – 2005
Melissa Gerbeth – 2007, 2008
Audrey Dalrymple – 2009, 2011, 2012
Ellie Watson – 2010, 2011

TENNIS

First Team
Katie Vales – 1998, 1999
Natalie Cook – 2001
Annie Knish – 2001, 2002
Jeannie Knish – 2002, 2003, 2004
Kristen Palombo – 2005
Kelly McDavitt – 2007
Camille Gebert – 2008, 2010
Jillian Hurley – 2009, 2010, 2011
Mary Catherine Faller – 2012, 2013
Monica Davy – 2018
Megan Davy – 2021
Lucy Chamberlin – 2023
Alayna Campbell – 2024

Second Team
Annie Knish – 1999, 2000
Natalie Cook – 2000
Jeannie Knish – 2001
Kaitlin Cutler – 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004
Kristen Palombo – 2003, 2004, 2006
Jillian Hurley – 2008
Camille Gebert – 2009
Mary Catherine Faller – 2014
Andrea Fetters – 2015, 2016
Monica Davy – 2016, 2017, 2019
Megan Davy – 2018, 2019
Lucy Chamberlin – 2022
Alayna Campbell – 2022, 2023
Evelyn Demblans-Dechans – 2024
Emma Kealy – 2024

TRACK AND FIELD

Allyson Treloar – 1998
Stacy Davis – 1999

VOLLEYBALL

First Team
Agnes Bill – 1998, 1999
Kristen Playko – 2003
Anne Cusack – 2006*
Lorna Slupczynski – 2009
Kati Schneider – 2012, 2013
Katie Hecklinski – 2015
Meaghan Gibbons – 2016
Rachel Bonek – 2017
Marielle Corbett – 2017*

Second Team
Suzanne Martin – 1998
Angie Meyers – 2000
Alison Shevik – 2003
Anne Cusack – 2005
Kristen Playko – 2006
Lorna Slupczynski – 2007, 2008
Cathy Kurczak – 2008
Meghann Rose – 2011
Katie Hecklinski – 2013
Kati Schneider – 2014
Kaylin Szucs – 2016
Audrey Shannon – 2017, 2018
Nicole Lukens – 2019
Megan Collantes – 2019
Colleen McCarthy – 2021, 2022

MIAA PLAYERS OF THE YEAR

MIAA Most Valuable Player
Stefanie Simmerman – Golf, 2003 (Co-MVP)
Julia Adams – Golf, 2004
Megan Mattia – Golf, 2005
Kristin Amram – Softball, 2006
Katie O'Brien – Golf, 2007
Alison Kessler – Basketball, 2008
Rosie O'Connor – Golf, 2008
Martyna Mierzwa – Golf, 2009
Ashley Peterson – Softball, 2010
Mary Kate Boyce – Golf, 2010
Samantha Averill – Golf, 2015
Cassie Young – Softball, 2016, 2017
Hunter Kehoe – Golf, 2018, 2019, 2021^
Haley Angel – Golf, 2024

MIAA Softball Most Valuable Pitcher
Morgan Raymer – 2018

MIAA Most Valuable Offensive Player
Erin Sullivan – Softball, 2004
Mary Singler – Lacrosse, 2017
Erin Doyle – Lacrosse, 2019, 2021

MIAA SPORTSMANSHIP AWARD WINNERS

GOLF 

Mary Kate Boyce, 2010*
Alexi Bown, 2013

TENNIS - Sue Little Sportsmanship Award

Betsy Gemmer, 1999
Natalie Cook, 2001
Elisa Ryan, 2003
Mary Catherine Faller, 2014
Megan Davy, 2019, 2021

MIAA SPECIAL AWARD WINNERS

SOCCER - Senior Sportswoman of the Year

Becca Stella, 2021

TENNIS - Karen Caine Scholar-Athlete Award

Andrea Fetters, 2016

Note: Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, Saint Mary's did not compete in basketball, cross country, soccer, or volleyball in the 2020-21 academic year.